Four ways to give ELL students feedback on their writing is the headline of one of my latest Teaching English – British Council posts.
I’ve been thinking and writing about the most effective ways to give feedback to students. I’ve obviously been trying to apply what I’ve been learning in the classroom, too.
As a one sentence summary, as I’ve posted about previously, the research says it’s best to praise effort and not intelligence.
Here are some resources I’ve found helpful:
What Kind Of Feedback Should We Give Our Students? is a post I have previously written.
The Difference Between Praise & Acknowledgment is another older post.
The Perils and Promises of Praise is an article by Carol Dweck.
It’s Not About How Smart You Are is an article by Carol Dweck.
Goodbye to “Good Job!”—The Power of Specific Feedback is a useful post by Margaret Berry Wilson at ASCD Express.
“The Praise Paradox” is an excerpt from the book Nurture Shock: New Thinking About Children, written by by Po Bronson and Ashley Merryman. It appeared in the March issue of “NEA Today.”
The words that could unlock your child comes from the BBC.
Carol Dweck’s website for her book, Mindset, contains a number of useful articles on her research, particularly on giving effective feedback.
Dr. Heidi Grant Halvorson has written a short article for Carol Dweck’s website. It provides a simple review of the basics on the kind of feedback we should be giving our students, and generally there’s nothing new in it. However, it did make one important point I have not see made anyplace else:
Avoid praising effort when it didn’t pay off. Many parents try to console their child by saying things like “Well honey, you didn’t do very well, but you worked hard and really tried your best.” Why does anyone think that this is comforting? For the record – it’s not. (Unless, of course, it was a no-win situation from the start).
Studies show that, after a failure, being complimented for “effort” not only makes kids feel stupid, it also leaves them feeling like they can’t improve. In these instances, it’s really best to stick to purely informational feedback – if effort isn’t the problem, help them figure out what is.
Unfortunately, she doesn’t provide references to those studies.
Use Acknowledgments More Than Praise is by Marvin Marshall.
How to Tell Whether You’re Using Praise or Acknowledgments is also by Marvin Marshall.
An article entitled Choice Words by Doug Fisher and Nancy Frey has been published by the National Association of Secondary School Principals, and it’s an exceptional commentary with practical suggestions on giving effective feedback. I especially like the framework they use — dividing helpful feedback into ones that emphasize student accomplishments, identity and agency.
How To Give Good Feedback is by Annie Murphy Paul.
This next piece is an excellent interview with Carol Dweck. I learn from all of her work, but I found this one particularly interesting because she shared some thoughts I hadn’t heard her say before.
Giving Feedback is by Elena Aguilar and is focuses on instructional coaches giving feedback to educators. However, most of the advice can be easily applied to students, as well.
Tips for Improving Feedback at the Middle Level is by Debbie Silver.
The Pajarao Valley Unified School District has an excellent collection of resources on Professor Carol Dweck’s work, and it’s been on The Best Resources On Helping Our Students Develop A “Growth Mindset” list for quite awhile.
However, they created another related resource that, for some reason, I discovered is not on that list. It’s an exceptional PowerPoint presentation on how to provide feedback to students that promotes a growth mindset. And, in an added bonus, a portion of it speaks directly to parents.
The Best Learning Motivator EVER! is by Eric Jensen.
The Difference Between Praise and Feedback is from MindShift.
Tips for Giving Feedback is from Elena Aguilar.
How to Turn Praise into Acknowledgment is by Marvin Marshall.
New Ideas on Feedback from IATEFL 2014 is an interesting post.
— Ian Landy (@Picsined) September 2, 2014
Pupils benefit from praise, but should teachers give it to them publicly or privately? is from Research Digest.
— @TeacherToolkit (@TeacherToolkit) March 4, 2015
Study: Feedback doesn’t always help students is from Chalkbeat.
— IDEO U (@IDEOU) December 2, 2015
Effective Feedback in the Classroom https://t.co/rlYnrMMvT7
— Lisa Eickholdt (@LisaEickholdt) December 21, 2015
This ASCD Article By Dylan Wiliam May Be The Best Article You’ll Ever Read On Giving Students Feedback
Additional suggestions are welcome.
— Brad Hurst (@brad_hurst) April 21, 2016
I’ve got questions about some of these recommendations, but I’m still adding it to this list:
Updated – what to mark v what NOT to mark following recommendations by the DfE Marking Policy Review Group report pic.twitter.com/qp96wfjGtw
— Gary King (@Gary_S_King) May 19, 2016
I don’t think I agree with everything Doug Lemov writes here, but a lot of it sounds useful: Positive Reinforcement: Distinguishing Praise from Acknowledgment in the Classroom.
How to Give Bad Feedback Without Being a Jerk is from Heleo.
Two Myths about Feedback (and Why the Myths are Wrong) is from The Learning Scientists.
— Rebecca Kinnee (@rkinnee) April 26, 2017
Save Grading Time and Provide Meaningful Feedback: It Is Possible is from Read It Write It Learn It.
Guiding student improvement without individual feedback is by Harry Fletcher-Wood.
A Marked Improvement: A review of the evidence on written marking is from The Education Endowment Foundation.
The Praise Paradox is from Behavioral Scientist.
I’m not sure I agree with this Dan Pink piece: Why you should always deliver the bad news first.
— Keith Devlin (@profkeithdevlin) March 13, 2018
Feedback Without Clarity is Meaningless…At Best is from Kristin Anderson.
‘Not All Feedback Is Created Equal’ is a four-part series in my Education Week Teacher column.
Ensuring students respond to feedback: Responsive Teaching 2019 update is from Improving Teaching.
How to get better at giving (and getting) feedback is from NBC News.
The Secret To Giving Great Feedback is a new and short TED Talk that offers a simple, but useful, formula to keep in mind when giving anyone feedback.
Good Feedback Is a Two-Way Conversation is from The Harvard Business Review.
New metaanalyses (reviews of multiple studies) confirm that substantive feedback WITHOUT GRADES is preferable for student motivation & achievement. Grades were worse than nothing at all re motivation to learn, w/most damage to struggling & older students: https://t.co/yiKyKUkCi0
— Alfie Kohn (@alfiekohn) August 14, 2020
The Anatomy of an Effective and Efficient Piece of Feedback is from Matthew M. Johnson.
Focused feedback: why less is more is by Harry Fetcher-Wood.
FEEDBACK A short guide to delivering effective and meaningful feedback to students is from Evidence Based Education.
8 Steps to Making Feedback More Effective is from Edutopia.
On Positive and Negative Feedback to Student Writing is by P.L. Thomas.
Feedback Isn’t Enough to Help Your Employees Grow is from The Harvard Business Review.
Another pearl of wisdom from @dylanwiliam: Feedback should be detective work, not information. What a great way to engage students in their own learning #LatB61 @learningandtheb pic.twitter.com/L0iEZetbc6
— Jennifer Howell (@jk_howell) February 20, 2022
Giving Feedback That Works: Plant the Seeds of Confidence is from the University of Pennsylvania.
Improving Feedback and Fostering Collaboration With Technology is from Edutopia.
Feedback on writing is such an important part of effective teaching and mentoring
Here’s my approach:
1. Identify a problem
(eg, this isn’t clear)
2. Explain why it’s a problem
(eg, the reader might think you mean…)
3. Offer possible solutions
(eg, instead you might say…) 1/ https://t.co/vHpO1LQYda
— Jess Calarco (@JessicaCalarco) May 21, 2022
If you found this post useful, you might want to consider subscribing to this blog for free.
You might also want to explore the 475 other “The Best…” lists I’ve compiled.